The Roundtree, Amagansett

The linen, towels pillows and mattress were the best. This is definitely 5 star quality. The staff and service is 5 star as well. I truly cannot think of a single thing they could improve upon. We stayed for 5 nights and thoroughly enjoyed the stay.

First, I think it’s totally unfair for Trip Advisor to include reviews of Roundtree for visits when it was under different management and a different name. You wouldn’t do that for a restaurant with a new chef and cuisine. Our three day stay at Roundtree was exceptional. Cabin was immaculate with top shelf everything - linens, pillows (email 3 days ahead of time asked type of pillows we wanted), free snacks, free beverages in refrigerator, Nespresso machine and capsules. Staff were attentive, lighting a fire in the fire pit every night, putting out s’mores kits every night, putting out freshly baked chocolate chip cookies every day, and bringing continental breakfast to the cabin every morning. The included items with the continental breakfast were varied, and any guest complaining that the continental breakfast didn’t include savory items needs to look up the definition of a continental breakfast! The property is amazing with lots of gathering spots away from the cabins. Make sure you visit the LongHouse Reserve nearby.

Comfortable bed and breakfast ($1500)but completely overcharged for what is provided.The accommodation is only satisfactory…good beds…showers no bath…Spartan facilities …it’s like an ikea room…( clean)but a price tag that in no way reflects value for money.A trayed acceptable breakfast….to say it’s a “ small hotel of the world”…quality is just not there. It’s very pleasant but for a price tag of $1500 a night it’s the worst value I’ve ever had in the USA. Impossible access if you have walking issues. It has a very cool buggy to get you to the beach…. It’s not even on the beach… no room phone…not porterage…..no management just a group of pleasant youngsters.Give this a miss unless you’ve wealth you need to dispose of🤦‍♂️