Four Columns Inn

We were in Newfane for a wedding celebration. Stayed at the Four Columns for two nights. Bridget and the staff were excellent. The facilities were clean and the room was very comfortable.

AMAZING MEAL with matching service. I cannot wait to return! We shared a Birthday Party for a 95 year old friend. In attendance, 94, 88, 68, 67 year olds. The courtesy, the amount of food we all thoroughly enjoyed, the care of each person attending to our party, as well as many others in the Tavern, was absolutely exceptional from the drinks and amuse bouche through the palate cleanser and dessert.

I can't say enough about this beautiful place. My sister and I visited and felt recharged after just one day. The front desk lady, Briget, made us feel very welcome and warm. She made us great tea in the library area. Our rooms are zen and cozy, and the fireplaces are even more comfortable. The breakfast is full of nice local pasties, a lot of coffee, and tea bags. We walked around the property and found a nice backyard stream. We sat there for quite a while. The water is clean and fresh. The sound of the water is healing. We would come back again for sure.

We had a lovely stay at the Four Columns Inn. This was our second time staying here, and our first under recent, new ownership. We were warmly welcomed upon our arrival and were taken to our suite. We stayed in the “Sting Suite” which is located on the 3rd floor of the front building with columns. The room is nicely decorated, with cathedral ceiling and two sided gas fireplace. The bathroom is spacious with double sinks, hot tub and shower. We appreciated having the mini fridge in the room. The bed was comfortable, a bit softer than we are used to. This room price is very expensive, so to give it more of an upscale feel I would suggest offering bathrobes, plusher towels and finer quality bed linens. For skiing and muddy weather, I would suggest adding a waterproof mat or place to put boots and damp ski gear, as we didn’t want to ruin the nice wooden floors. The inn offers a continental breakfast that includes coffee, tea, juice, limited fruit and pastry. We were disappointed with the selection of pastries and fruit, and felt there could be more variety and home baked options. There are very few places nearby for hot breakfast so being able to get a hot breakfast at the hotel would be my suggestion for a future offerings. We ate dinner at the hotel’s restaurant 1832 Tavern. The restaurant serves tavern food. The food was ok, very basic. Our server was very inexperienced, which led to some disappoint with our meal and dining experience. The manager spoke to us and gave us complementary desert to make up for it. There are very few dining options in Newfane so I hope the restaurant can provide more compelling food options and improve service. Overall our stay was very pleasant and comfortable. The inn is lovely and the staff is kind and helpful. For the new management, I hope these suggestions are helpful.

Went to dinner for my birthday. We sat in the tavern. At least 5 minutes passed before a server acknowledges us. She brought water , but no glasses were on the table. There was then a brief discussion with the bartender as to which glasses to use. I then had to point out that we had no menus. After reviewing the menu for a few minutes the server returned to ask if we wanted to start with an appetizer. I asked what the soup of the day was and we were told. My husband ordered the lobster bisque. I notified the server that I am gluten intolerant and inquired about substitutions for the pasta that accompanies my desired entree. My husband then felt pressured to order his entree, despite not having made his selection. We waited 20* minutes and all the food came out at once. It is my understanding that appetizers should come BEFORE a meal. We were finished with our meals, but the server was nowhere to be found. The bartender ended up clearing our plates and giving up our bill. Still no server around. The chicken I ordered was tough, my husband’s fish was poorly cooked. The quality of the food does NOT match the prices they charge.

The Four Columns Inn owes me $752 that it promised to pay but hasn't. I cancelled the reservation for two rooms because their on site restaurant (where we had made a reservation) had closed and the reason for staying at the inn was to have a nice celebration dinner at the restaurant on 10/5/23 after a 4 day leaf-peek hike in Vermont. A month before I googled and saw that the restaurant had closed I was contacted fairly quickly by the Inn and told that the place is under new management and that we would receive the refund, but that the previous owner had not transferred the deposit to the new owner and I should be patient. Now they don't return my calls.